Slavophile Perceptions of “Russian” and “Russianness” in the Late 1830s and the First Half of the 1840s
Abstract
The notion of “narodnost’’ was one of the central concepts in Russian discussions of the 1820s–1840s, first in literary criticism and then, from the early 1830s, it acquired official status. At the same time, it became a question rather than a designation of something at least relatively clear and definite, as evidenced by the literary disputes about “narodnost” and “prostonarodnost” of the 1820s and early 1830s. The enormous contribution to the concretisation of the notion of “narodnost” as applied to Russia, to the saturation of Slavophilism’s notions of “Russian” and “Russianness” is beyond doubt, regardless of the assessments given to this contribution. This article focuses on the early period of Slavophilism, from the late 1830s, when the Slavophile circle began to take shape, to the mid-1840s, when Slavophilism had already clearly taken shape and, among other things, was able to produce a number of texts (the preface to the Valuyev’s “Collection…” in 1845, the polemic with “Sovremennik” in 1847), which were perceived and are perceived to this day with due reason as “manifestos” of the direction. The article analyses the texts of the main authors of the Slavophile trend of this time: A. S. Khomyakov, Yu. F. Samarin, K. S. Aksakov, D. A. Valuyev and I. V. Kireyevsky, and demonstrates the directions of concretisation of the concept. Particular attention is paid to the logic of singling out Orthodoxy as a constitutive characteristic of “Russian” and the tension of this construction.
Downloads
References
Aksakov K. S. (1995) Aesthetics and Literary Criticism (сomposition, text preparation, introductory article and commentary by V. A. Koshelev), Moscow: Art.
Aksakov K. S. (1861) The Complete Works of Konstantin Sergeyevich Aksakov, vol. I (ed. by I. S. Aksakov), Moscow: Tip. P. Bakhmetev.
Annenkov P. V. (1928) Literary Memoirs (preface by N. K. Piksanov; introduction, ed. and notes by B. M. Eichenbaum), Leningrad: Academia.
Azadovsky M. K. (2013) History of Russian folkloristics, in 2 vols, vol. 1, Moscow: OSTU Pub.
Azadovsky M. K. (1934) “N. M. Yazykov”, Yazykov N. M. Complete Collection of Poems (ed., intro. article and comments by M. K. Azadovsky), Moscow; Leningrad: Academia, pp. 12–81.
Elagin N. A. (1911) “Materials for the biography of I. V. Kireevsky”, The Complete Works of Ivan Vasilyevich Kireevsky, in 2 vols, vol. I (ed. by M. O. Gershenzon), Moscow: Put’.
Kireevsky I. V. (2018) The Complete Collection of Works, in 3 vols, vol. 1: 1816–1839 (under the general ed. by A. N. Nikolyukin), Saint Petersburg: Rostok.
Kireevsky P. V. (1935) Letters of P. V. Kireevsky to N. M. Yazykov (ed. and commentary by M. K. Azadovsky), Moscow; Leningrad: Academy of Sciences of the USSR.
Khomyakov A. S. (1900) The Complete Works of Alexei Stepanovich Khomyakov, in 8 vols, vol. III, Moscow: University Printing House on Strastnoy Boulevard.
Khomyakov A. S. (1994) Works, in 2 vols, vol. 1: Works on Historiosophy (introduction, compl. and text preparation by V. A. Koshelev), Moscow: Moscow Philosophical Foundation.
Khristoforov I. A. (2011) Fate of the Reform: Russian Peasantry in Government Policy before and after the Abolition of Serfdom (1830–1890s), Moscow: Sobranie.
Kostomarov N. I. (2018) Two Russian Nationalities: A Collection, in 2 vols (ed. by A. A. Teslya), Moscow: RIPOL-Classic.
Mann Yu. V. (1969) Russian Philosophical Aesthetics, Moscow: Art.
Pirozhkova T. F. (1997) Slavophile Journalism, Moscow: MSU Pub.
Pypin A. N. (1906) Characteristics of Literary Opinions from the Twenties to the Fifties. Historical Sketches, 3rd ed., Saint Petersburg: Kolos Book Publishing House.
Teslya A. A. (2016) “‘Russian People’ and ‘Russian State’: N. A. Polevoy vs N. M. Karamzin”, Notebook on Conservatism, no. 4, pp. 81–95.
Teslya A. A. (2017) “‘Ukrainophile’ in the ‘all-Russian’ Context: The Publicist N. I. Kostomarov 1861–1883”, New Literary Review, no. 2 (144), pp. 137–153.
Tsimbaev N. I. (1986) Slavophilism: From the History of Russian Socio-Political Thought of the 19th Century, Moscow: MSU Pub.
Valuev D. A. (2010) The Beginnings of Slavophilism (compiled, preface and commentary by Yu. V. Klimakov; ed. by O. A. Platonov), Moscow: Institute of Russian Civilisation.
Veselovsky A. N. (1918) V. A. Zhukovsky. Poetry of Feeling and “Heart Imagination”, Petrograd: Book Publishing House ‘‘Life and Knowledge’’.
Walicki A. (2019) W kręgu konserwatywnej utopii. Struktura i przemiany rosyjskiego słowianofilstwa, Moscow: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie.
Works by Yu. F. Samarin (1911), vol. XII: Letters 1840–1853, Moscow: Comradeship Typ. A. I. Mamontov.
Zenkovsky V. V. (1961) Fundamentals of Christian Philosophy, vol. 1, Münich: Posev.
Zorin A. L. (2001) Feeding the Two-Headed Eagle... Russian Literature and State Ideology in the Last Third of the 18th — First Third of the 19th Century, Moscow: New Literary Review.
